The first parishes to be established in the east of the Diocese of Ross followed the fertile coastlands, which were important for agriculture and maritime trade, as well as for several ferry crossings that enabled travellers heading north or south to avoid the long detour via Beauly and Dingwall. The region was relatively settled under the auspices of influential families such as the Mactaggart Earls of Ross, who encouraged the establishment of religious houses following the legislative reforms introduced during the reign of David I (1124-53). The first cathedral church was built at Rosemarkie on the Black Isle, to be replaced by that of the nearby Fortrose chanonry in the mid-13th century. The diocese expanded, eventually embracing 37 parishes, the revenues of which were appropriated to support the cathedral.
The relative wealth and density of the population in Easter Ross was reflected in the easterly distribution of castles and mansions and in the arrangement of the parishes. Those on the coastal lowlands and Braes of Ross (the zone of hills to the east of the mountain spine) were physically small in size compared to the parishes in the remainder of the county of Ross.
Some of the sites of churches and chapels may have had Pictish antecedents. Only remnants have survived from a pre-Reformation religious landscape that included not only churches and chapels, but also shrines and holy wells. Medieval churches were built on an east-west alignment, with a floorplan that placed everyone facing eastwards when they worshipped, so that the light coming through the window from the rising sun would remind worshippers of the resurrection of Christ. The churches were supplemented by chapels, often privately endowed by the wealthy.
The Reformation of 1560 brought with it legislation in the Scottish parliament that established a radically new protestant church based on the Presbyterian model of Calvin’s reformed church in Geneva. During the 17th century, when the Stuart kings imposed changes on its structure and doctrine, the Covenanters emerged as a religious and political movement in support of Presbyterian government of the Church of Scotland. They advocated the primacy of congregations in religious affairs and the idea of a ‘Covenant’ between the people of Scotland and God. At the opposite end of the spectrum were Episcopalians, who supported government by bishops. They controlled the church from 1584 to 1638 and from 1661 to 1689. After the Restoration of 1660, the Covenanters became a persecuted group, immersed in rebellions, bitter factions and killings. Presbyterian government of the Church was re-established after the Glorious Revolution of 1688, when James VII was ousted in favour of William and Mary.
The doctrinal changes introduced at the Reformation were relatively slow to make their mark in the Highlands, where parish churches were frequently ruinous and ministers often badly paid and poorly housed. Re-ordering was not a priority for heritors, other than in the wealthiest of parishes or where the church reflected the power and status of an important local family, as at Kiltearn and Alness. Yet medieval structures—usually simple, un-aisled rectangles—lent themselves fairly easily to the new theological and liturgical requirements and, over time, many underwent change and adaptation. Where new churches were built, they often occupied an earlier site and adopted the narrow, rectangular form and east/west alignment of their predecessor.
The emphasis of worship in the Presbyterian church was on communal prayer, the singing of psalms and the preaching of the Word. The Lord’s Supper (Communion) was celebrated only infrequently and any hint of an altar was eliminated. The pulpit was now the focal point of the interior, placed at the heart of the congregation—usually at the centre of the south wall, where the light was best—so that the minister could be seen by all. By deconsecrating and reordering the sanctuary, a fair amount of additional space could be gained for pews without the need for making major changes to the main fabric, other than repositioning some of the windows. The seating was arranged to bring worshippers as close as possible to the preacher, with galleries (or lofts) constructed to maximise the accommodation.
By the late 17th century, schemes of enlargement were common. Typical works included heightening the walls and knocking out part of the rear elevation in order to add a transept aisle opposite the pulpit, making the church T-plan, as at Cromarty and Nigg.
During the 18th century, worshippers celebrated Communion in small groups at a pew or table below the pulpit. As the number of communicants grew, permanent long tables, lined on both sides with benches, were installed, set more visibly in front of the pulpit. Sometimes pews were folded out to make a series of tables.
Architectural decoration was rare, most churches being utilitarian preaching boxes, their windows and doorways usually rectangular and unornamented. Often, a bellcote on the west gable was the only external feature of note. Easter Ross has its own distinctive group of plain belfries with corner pinnacles, two of the best examples being at Cromarty and Nigg.
By the later-18th century, a more elaborate style of building, inspired perhaps by churches designed by the leading Scottish born architect James Gibbs, had begun to emerge in cities and large burghs to accommodate the growing urban population. Typical features included Classical spires, piended (hipped) roofs and pairs of tall windows flanking the central pulpit on the long principal elevation, with vertically-paired windows in the outer bays. Inside, broad, shallow galleries were arranged in U-plan around the pulpit. The influence of this more sophisticated church architecture can be seen at Dingwall and Rosskeen.
In the last decade of the 18th century, the early Gothic Revival spread north. In places of worship, it manifested itself in a fusion of English village church exterior and Presbyterian kirk interior dubbed ‘Heritors’ Gothic’. Pointed arches, timber Y-tracery, pinnacled buttresses and crocketed finials adorned naves and bell towers. The church at Rosemarkie is an example within this survey.
The string of parishes around the Cromarty Firth had for long been a hotbed of activity for evangelicals, with many instances of long-running disputes between ‘Moderate’ ministers, heritors and ‘the Men’, as the lay leaders of these evangelical congregations were known. However, probably because the religious differences of the 18th century were primarily about church government rather than doctrine, they were only to a limited extent reflected in the character of the buildings. Generally in the Highlands, churches continued to be built or modified to the standard format well into the 19th century.
Between 1825 and 1835, a range of plain, adaptable T-plan churches with simple Tudor detail was built for the new ‘Parliamentary parishes’ created in congested districts of the Highlands. Designed, together with an accompanying manse, by William Thomson, they were constructed under the supervision of Thomas Telford. Although none are located within the area covered by this survey, these Parliamentary churches set a minimal standard for such buildings in the Highlands and islands and would have influenced some of the rural church designs included here.
As the wealth and power of the non-landowning middle classes increased, grumbling discontent with the role of the heritors in church governance—notably the patronage system of appointing ministers—bubbled back to the surface, polarizing opinion within the Church. The culminating event was the momentous Disruption of 1843. It took place at the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland that year, when ministers and elders staged a mass walk-out and immediately proceeded to form the Free Church of Scotland.
With its traditions of evangelicalism and staunch commitment to Presbyterian church government, it was no surprise that Easter Ross embraced the Disruption and that there was a widespread exodus to the Free Church. Indeed, with the exception of Dingwall, the ministers of all of the parishes encircling the Cromarty Firth joined the Free Church. This left many of the remaining congregations struggling, their dwindling size reflected in such changes as the boarding-up of church lofts and the closing-off of the spaces below them.
Meanwhile, there was an urgent requirement for new Free Church buildings and these, along with the ministers’ stipends, had to be financed mainly by the members of the congregation. Accommodation rather than architectural flourish was the immediate goal and there is little evidence in the Highlands at this time of any attempt to embrace the more scholarly strain of the Gothic style that would become widely associated with Victorian church architecture.
In the late 1880s, under the influence of the Tractarian Movement in England, sections of the Church of Scotland began to adopt a more pre-Reformation pattern of worship and interior design. The Communion table was now placed in a separate chancel, backed by a wooden screen, or reredos, and sometimes flanked by choir stalls. The pulpit was moved to the junction of the chancel and the nave, often with a prayer desk opposite. Where existing church interiors were adapted, their layout was turned through 90 degrees to suit the new arrangement.
In 1929, the Church of Scotland amalgamated with the United Free Church of Scotland, itself the product of earlier unions. As a result, some kirks became redundant, often after decades of maintaining two buildings, as at Cromarty, where the larger United Free Church eventually replaced the East Church as the principal place of worship. It is worth mentioning that there are no modern Church of Scotland buildings within the area surveyed.
In recent years, the problem of dwindling congregations has become acute and the Church of Scotland is threatening to close and sell hundreds of its buildings—including, in this area, Urray West Parish Church near Muir of Ord and Killearnan Parish Church at Milton on the Black Isle. It is therefore more important than ever that we understand the significance of these churches and do everything we can to help protect them from falling derelict or being insensitively altered, while suggesting practical and creative ways of enabling them to continue to be used in sympathetic ways that do not compromise their historic interest and architectural integrity.
THE GRAVEYARDS
Most of the post-Reformation kirkyards visited are still in use, many incorporating earlier burial grounds, some with significant medieval survivals. David Alston makes an interesting observation relating to religious tolerance in some parishes in the area following the Reformation. He has singled out two significant grave slabs—the late-medieval stone carved with a pierced hand and chalice at Cullicudden (Roman Catholic) and a 1720s one depicting the crucifixion at Urquhart (Episcopalian)—and notes that neither have been defaced, as they might well have been elsewhere. However, the Kirkmichael Trust’s ongoing study of ornate medieval crosses includes a depressing number of chiselled-off—or sometimes just broken-off—cross heads from the Black Isle and Easter Ross.
From 1581, burial inside functioning churches was forbidden, although some redundant chancels were converted to burial vaults for prominent families. From the 17th century, new mausolea and burial enclosures, sometimes joined to the church, began to appear in churchyards, along with rustic Classical detail. Some Pictish and medieval stones were partly reused as grave markers, as at Kiltearn. All these memorials were for prominent members of society; indeed, until the 17th century, the graves of most ordinary people were left unmarked. Increasingly, however, those who could afford it commissioned slabs, table stones (a slab elevated by two end pieces) and headstones. Many of these survive in the burial grounds visited in this survey, along with an array of Victorian monuments, some on a massive scale, and the polished, machine-cut funerary masonry of today. Some of the sites also include memorials put up by the Commonwealth War Graves Commission.
See www.kirkmichael.info for the Kirkmichael Trust’s project to record, conserve and present a remarkable collection of medieval and later gravemarkers.
This introduction and the church descriptions were written by Mary Miers, incorporating information and some excerpts from texts by John Hume, David Alston, Andrew Wright and John Gifford. David Alston and Malcolm Bangor-Jones provided some additional editorial input.
